
Can Your Constitutional Rights Be Taken Away?
Season 2 Episode 4 | 14m 54sVideo has Closed Captions
Where do ‘rights’ come from? Ben Sheehan explains what the Constitution does, and doesn’t, include.
Many of your rights aren’t in the Bill of Rights. So, where are they? Ben Sheehan explains how laws, court rulings, and state constitutions play a role. Then, constitutional scholar Eugene Volokh illustrates how judges recognize ‘unenumerated’ rights. Finally, retired judge Vaughn Walker recounts striking down California’s same-sex marriage ban and its incompatibility with the 14th Amendment.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback

Can Your Constitutional Rights Be Taken Away?
Season 2 Episode 4 | 14m 54sVideo has Closed Captions
Many of your rights aren’t in the Bill of Rights. So, where are they? Ben Sheehan explains how laws, court rulings, and state constitutions play a role. Then, constitutional scholar Eugene Volokh illustrates how judges recognize ‘unenumerated’ rights. Finally, retired judge Vaughn Walker recounts striking down California’s same-sex marriage ban and its incompatibility with the 14th Amendment.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Civics Made Easy
Civics Made Easy is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship- Our constitutional rights.
To some, they're the most important part of the document.
They protect us from tyranny at the hands of Earth's most powerful government.
But if you open the Constitution, which I assume like me you do for fun, a lot of the rights you have or think you have aren't in here.
So how can a right be constitutional if it isn't in the Constitution?
That seems like something we should probably understand.
I'm Ben Sheehan, and this is "Civics Made Easy."
A brief history of our enumerated constitutional rights.
Enumerated means written down.
On September 17th, 1787, 39 dudes signed the Constitution, and that OG version included some rights.
The right to elect members of the House.
If you're detained by law enforcement, you have the right to see a judge to find out why.
You can't be punished for a crime without a trial.
You can't be charged retroactively for doing something that wasn't illegal when you did it.
And you can't be convicted of treason unless at least two witnesses saw the crime.
And if you did commit treason, your kids can't also be punished unless they were involved.
But when it came time to sign the Constitution, some delegates didn't think those rights were enough, like Edmund Randolph, Elbridge Gerry, who you may remember from our gerrymandering episode, he's the namesake, and George Mason.
They were worried that this new federal government would be too powerful.
States could lose their autonomy.
Most concerningly, the Constitution had no Bill of Rights to protect individuals from federal government overreach, so they refused to sign, the only ones to do so.
George Mason went even further.
Years earlier, he'd written Virginia's Bill of Rights, which Thomas Jefferson used heavily as a model for the Declaration of Independence.
He kind of copied his homework.
Mason believed that human rights were inherent, natural, things like life, liberty, and the means of getting and having property, safety, and happiness.
So Mason wrote down his objections to the Constitution and they went viral, which back then meant got passed around.
That made supporters of the Constitution, like James Madison, pretty nervous.
Madison had thought that a Bill of Rights was not necessary.
Many states already had their own, and the Constitution clearly limited federal power.
He also had another concern.
If only some rights were written down, would people assume those were their only rights?
But after pressure from Jefferson and others and with his election to Congress on the line, Madison changed his mind.
He promised states that were still on the fence, "If you ratify the Constitution, "then I, James Madison, will introduce a Bill of Rights "to add as amendments."
And it worked.
On June 21st, 1788, New Hampshire became the ninth state to ratify the Constitution, and it took effect the following year.
So what were some of those rights Madison introduced?
He actually wrote 19 amendments.
As a single 38-year-old man, he had free time.
The House approved 17 of those.
Of those 17, the Senate approved 12.
And of those 12, the states ratified 10.
And those first 10 constitutional amendments became our Bill of Rights in 1791.
So here's what's in them.
Freedom of speech, religion, press, the right to gather peacefully in groups, the right to ask the government, initially Congress, now any branch, to fix something that's unfair, the right to bear arms, not being forced to house soldiers, which is a major declaration complaint, protections against unreasonable search and seizure of you, your home, or your stuff.
And then there's a ton of rights involving the legal process, like you can't be tried for a serious crime without an indictment, a charge from a grand jury.
You can't be tried twice for the same crime or forced to testify against yourself or have your life, liberty, or property taken without a fair legal process, the right to not have your land taken for government use without a fair payment for it, which doesn't really sound like a right.
I promise we're almost done.
If you're criminally charged, your trial must be fast in public with an impartial jury of your peers.
You get to hear what you're being charged with to confront witnesses testifying against you.
You can force people to testify on your behalf.
You get a defense lawyer, a trial by jury even in civil cases, which are disputes between private parties where the punishment is having to pay money, not serve jail time.
You can't be tried twice for the same civil infraction.
And last but definitely not least, no excessive bail, fines, or cruel and unusual punishment.
Remember, before the Revolutionary War, England was not kind to the colonists.
Judges were corrupt.
There were no jury trials.
Some colonists were kidnapped and taken back to the king to stand trial for fake crimes.
Some were executed.
So Madison really stressed to the skeptics that this new big central government was gonna be fair with the legal stuff.
But that's the end of what they wrote down, at least at first.
So what about everything else?
There are two final amendments to the Bill of Rights.
The 10th says if the Constitution doesn't give a power to the federal government or say that a state can't do it, then it's a state power or for we the people to handle.
But the 9th Amendment says something much different.
Essentially, just because some rights are listed or enumerated in the Constitution, that doesn't mean they're our only rights, which brings us back to the initial question.
What are those other unlisted, unenumerated rights?
Where are they?
And who gets to decide that they exist?
Well, I've got the right guy to ask.
Eugene Volokh from our democracy episode is now our residential constitutional expert, though he resides elsewhere.
Eugene, how can Americans have constitutional rights that aren't enumerated or mentioned in the Constitution?
- Well, chiefly because the Supreme Court has at times concluded there are such rights.
For a while that was true of the right to abortion.
It remains true of parental rights.
It's true of the right to use contraceptives.
It's true of the right to sexual autonomy.
But in our system, the Supreme Court interprets the Constitution and sometimes it interprets it in ways that seem to create new rights that are not expressly mentioned.
And the Supreme Court has rightly or wrongly recognized and sometimes stopped recognizing certain kinds of rights.
- Is there a big difference between a right that is written in the document and a right that isn't in there but has been recognized by the Supreme Court?
- Well, yes, because what the court has recognized, it could de-recognize.
That's what happened with abortion rights, which were recognized in Roe v. Wade in 1973, then were very controversial, and eventually the court reversed in the Dobbs decision.
More in principle, the court could do that to enumerated rights as well.
But if a right is in the Constitution, it's a lot more secure against a possible future Supreme Court change.
Whereas what the Supreme Court has created, the Supreme Court can take away as well.
- If we're being honest, when the Supreme Court or any federal court recognizes a constitutional right that isn't listed in the document, how is that not just the judges creating or granting a new right?
Isn't recognizing or interpreting a right just some judge's opinion?
- Yeah, it is judges' opinions and that's one reason some people are not fond of unenumerated rights.
Well, one possible distinction is between the courts recognizing rights that had long been assumed, even if not written down.
One example is the general right of parents to raise their children and have custody of their children.
The Supreme Court has recognized such a right starting with the 1920s and has continued to recognize it with relatively little dissent, in part because it's just been so long understood that this is part of the basics of American law.
- So what you're saying is that for unenumerated rights, judges tend to look to a history and tradition of those rights maybe being recognized by federal law or in state constitutions or by state law before making their decision?
- Right.
Many of the unenumerated rights that we talk about are indeed rights that have been recognized as a matter of history and tradition.
Those are probably the ones that are most secure of the unenumerated rights.
Whereas unenumerated rights that look like innovations look like a result of judges basically just saying, "We think this is right," rather than American history has treated this as a right.
- So the Bill of Rights, they protect you from the federal government, but it doesn't say they protect you from your state, but over the years, the Supreme Court has said that they do.
How did they reach that conclusion?
- Sure, so following the Civil War, which was fought in large part because of a sense that states were actually becoming oppressive, the 14th Amendment restrains states.
It says no state shall do various things.
The Supreme Court has interpreted the 14th Amendment as basically applying the Bill of Rights to the States.
It's called the Incorporation Doctrine.
You're incorporating the Bill of Rights into the 14th Amendment as a constraint on the states.
- It turns out this whole constitutional rights thing is pretty complicated.
Obviously, Madison left stuff out and admitted so.
So decades later, we added more rights to the Constitution's text, like birthright citizenship, equal protection of the laws, the right for we the people to elect our senators, preventing people from losing their voting rights because of their race, color, sex, or ability to pay a tax and being at least 18 years old.
But if you read the fine print, the Constitution doesn't say who can vote.
It just says that you can't lose that right because of the traits I mentioned, which means our right to vote, as we learned about in our voting rights episode, comes from state constitutions, as do many other rights.
Some state constitutions like Montana's and Pennsylvania's include the right to a clean, healthy environment.
Many state constitutions guarantee the right to a free public school education.
Some include workers' rights, reproductive rights, and protections from discrimination.
But because this is confusing, I've made a chart.
Let's start at number one.
The Constitution, that's the supreme law of the land.
Below that are federal laws which are passed by Congress and which cannot contradict the Constitution and are limited to what the document allows.
Then there are state constitutions, those are the supreme law of your state, which also can't contradict the US Constitution or federal law.
And then there are state laws, which can't contradict your state's constitution or the federal stuff.
And finally, there are court rulings which interpret those four tiers.
The higher the interpreted tier, the stronger the right.
But you can also look at these tiers as floors.
The US Constitution establishes a floor for our rights that federal laws and the states can't go below.
But they can go above it, like a federal law protecting your voting rights even more than the Constitution does, or a state constitution or state law that goes beyond the federal level, like a higher minimum wage than the federal amount of $7.25 an hour.
But if you really want to know how all this works, it might be good to ask someone who's directly involved, specifically with number five.
Vaughn Walker is a retired federal judge.
Nominated by President George H.W.
Bush and confirmed by the Senate in 1989, he spent more than two decades on the US District Court for the Northern District of California.
He should be able to help clarify this.
Judge Walker, you used to be a judge.
Someone comes into your courtroom and says, "I have this constitutional right," but the words don't appear in the US Constitution.
Where do you start?
- Well, there are a series of rights that are implicit in those rights that have been held to apply, notwithstanding the fact that they are not spelled out in words in the Constitution itself.
Probably the most prominent of which is the right of privacy.
It's not a right that is explicitly stated in the Constitution, but I think it is agreed by virtually everyone that it is implicit in the constitutional guarantees that the Constitution provides.
- How much weight do you give precedent?
How much should prior decisions by judges on our rights influence your thinking?
- Well, first of all, it depends on which courts you're talking about.
If it's the Supreme Court of the United States, then that carries a lot of weight.
If it's a appellate court in the district in which you sit, that carries a good deal of weight.
If it's some other judge who's on the same level that you are, it's what is called persuasive authority, and you may consider it to be something that you should follow.
But if it is not binding on you, you're not required to follow it, and you can simply take it for what you feel it's worth.
- A lot of people don't know this, but you are largely the reason that people of the same sex can get married here in California because you are best known for striking down Proposition 8, a state constitutional amendment that had banned same-sex marriage.
What about that amendment did you think violated the US Constitution?
- Well, it conflicted with the principles of substantive due process, including the right of privacy.
People are entitled to select their intimate personal relationships, but that is something that I think and has been recognized to be beyond the ability of the courts and the legislature and even the public through the initiative process to interfere with.
I think of my mother's comment about two people who you wonder how they ever got together, married one another, and her observation was, "Well, it didn't ruin two marriages," and it's not a bad way to look at these situations.
- So our constitutional rights aren't as simple as a list in a document.
Some are written, enumerated, in the US Constitution, some are written into state constitutions, and others have been recognized or unrecognized by judges.
We also have legal rights that are not constitutional.
Those come from federal or state laws rather than the US Constitution or your states'.
My point here is this, when someone says, "I have the right to do whatever," there's a follow-up question worth asking, "Where did that right come from?"
Some may cite the Declaration of Independence, which says our rights come from God, but the declaration is not a legally enforceable document, so what legal source enumerates or recognizes that right?
Because the answer will tell you who protects that right, who hears challenges to it, how that right can change, and how it can go away.
And also, it can tell us how rights can be added because the list of our rights isn't finished, and deciding what belongs on it, that's still up to us.
I'm Ben Sheehan, and I hope you learned something.
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Today's top journalists discuss Washington's current political events and public affairs.
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode

New Episode


Support for PBS provided by: